Discussion about this post

User's avatar
richardstevenhack's avatar

Thanks for the shout-out, Rob! Appreciated!

"Russia will ask Ukraine to become part of a political and economic union with Belarus and Russia."

I'd say it's likely to be more Russia TELLING Ukraine to become part of the CSTO. :-)

That also assumes that Russia will continue to want a separate state entity called "Ukraine". That may be probable, but I could see Russia just deciding to incorporate all of the previous entity called "Ukraine" into the Russian Federation. They might go through the motions of holding referendums in each oblast as they did the eastern oblasts, since the Russians are sticklers about legality. Ukraine was recognized as a sovereign state previously which would complicate relations with the UN based on the fact that nations aren't supposed to acquire territory by conquest any more (although Russia already has - not to mention Israel.)

But I suspect that most Ukrainians, regardless of their brainwashing, given the choice between living in a broken, economically dead "Ukraine" and being part of the Russian Federation economy and government will choose to go along with being incorporated into Russia.

In any event, based on my view that the goal of the war is for Russia to secure the far borders of Ukraine against NATO, it's fairly obvious that putting a Military District in western Ukraine is pretty much going to require Russia telling, rather than asking, Ukraine to go along with whatever arrangement Russia wants.

Since the current Ukraine government are "wanted criminals", and since Russia will have to capture and control Kiev at some point, regardless of how the Ukraine military surrenders (also at some point), it's likely that Russia will appoint an occupation government - military or civilian - in Kiev immediately after that surrender. Then they can either appoint a new civilian Ukraine government or even hold elections at some point.

Since the Ukrainian political scene is in disarray due to many parties being banned by the Zelensky regime, organizing the latter will be a challenge and take time. How many of those parties would be interested in joining the victorious Russian side out of self-interest will be interesting.

Depending on how far down the line that point occurs, the Russian Military District is likely to already be underway. All of this will likely take months well into 2025.

Just to drop a note about the Gaza situation and the Iran attack... I watched this interview with MIT Professor Theodore Postol yesterday on Colonel Daniel Davis' Deep Dive Youtube channel (recommend the channel as he has people like Colonel Macgregor on frequently). Postol explains why the Israeli Iron Dome system is total crap and probably has a 6% intercept capability, So all the US/Israeli claims of "all Iranian missiles shot down" are utter garbage. Postol is well known as a critic of the Patriot as well as the Iron Dome. Very informative interview.

Israel's Iron Dome: NOT What You Think w/MIT professor Ted Postol

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GIZJb0dWHho

Expand full comment
Michael boyd's avatar

Katyusha is perhaps the greatest patriotic song of all...worthy of the sacrifice the Soviets made. I'm surprised by the Ukrainian attacks during the great war celebrations. I don't know if you have ever followed the military artefact collectors on the eastern front. Many of the German and Soviet dead are basically still lying where they fell. I still disagree with the Russians taking over the whole of Ukraine. Your previous post showed an abundance of Bandera statues in the West and the Western Ukrainians hate the Russians. As i said before they have convinced themselves that the Russians were responsible for the famines and what they call the Holodomor. They'll open the border to the Poles before the Russians get there. They might even form a unified entity between Poland and Western Ukraine. The Germans mystify me with their tolerance towards their Atlanticist political elite. The political class is completely acting against the national interest and as surveys show the Germans generally speaking are well disposed towards the Russians , the Ostdeutsch in particular,, which seems counterintuitive, but is true.

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts